Yes, I want to pay for that
My last psychiatrist was terrible.
Before every session, you fill out a form talking about how you’re feeling and so on as a way to evaluate whether or not your ADHD meds are working properly. For months, I’d invariably mention something about feeling pretty shitty about the political climate: ICE kidnapping people, trans folks having their very right to exist attacked, and so on.
In our session, she’d always ask me, without fail:
But how does that affect you personally?
I’m a cishet white male with a strong social net. It doesn’t really affect me directly at all.
But it affects me personally because I give a shit about other people, and want to see everyone happy and successful and thriving, and holy shit what an absolutely awful question to ask someone.
I see a similar conversation happen often around social services, like, “why should your taxes pay for…”
- Other people to go to college?
- Kids to eat for free at school?
- Free housing for a homeless person?
- Candy and junk food for someone on SNAP/food stamps?
- Someone less healthy than you to have surgery?
- Rehab for someone struggling with addiction?
- A vacation or fun experience for someone whose disabled and can’t work?
- Clothes for someone who can’t afford them?
- A toy or video game for a kid whose parents don’t work?
The answer is simple: I give a shit about people.
I don’t get why this is weird or confusing or controversial to anyone. I care about people, and I want to see everyone be happy and thrive.
If you want to be a selfish asshole about it, we all do better when we all do better.
- A better educated population means a better chance of curing chronic illnesses, solving social challenges, and inventing cool new stuff.
- Kids who aren’t hungry learn better.
- People who have homes are more likely to work and less likely to use drugs or alcohol.
- Keeping someone alive means they can work and participate in society.
- Helping someone beat addiction means can work and participate in society.
- Keeping people clothed means they can leave the damn house, work, and participate in society.
But like… I don’t give a shit if someone is “productive” or not.
Everyone deserves joy and dignity and compassion, which is why I want folks on SNAP or food stamps to be able to buy candy. I want poor people to experience rest and have vacations and for their kids to have toys and fun experiences.
I give a shit about people.
Isn’t it weird how people never ask this question about all of the awful things are taxes actually do get used for right now, today? As a US citizen, my taxes are used to…
- Murder children in Gaza.
- Bail out billionaires.
- Spy on citizens.
- Kidnap minorities and ship them to illegal labor prisons.
- Clutter space with
space trashinternet satellites that fuck up astronomy. - Poison the water, soil, and air with industrial waste.
- Rapidly accelerate planetary warming.
I’d much rather some poor kid gets a hot meal or someone who will never work gets to eat a fucking Snickers bar than any of those things.
Because I give a shit about people.
If you’re upset at the idea that your tax money might prevent someone from dying but not upset that your taxes are used to literally murder people, you’re the weirdo, not me.